I was asked and honored to speak at this year’s Grand Valley Interfaith Network’s ThanksGVIN celebration during the week of Interfaith Awareness. Representing Nativity, I offered the following thoughts. This was a hard microtalk to write; the subject matter I present below has for me, as a student of Luther, greater temporal and spiritual implications and consequences than I was able to do them justice here. Gratitude and Giving, becoming one who can give to just give demands an encounter with God by faith that brings me out of death into new life; I must be recreated; I must justified by faith in Christ alone by God’s grace alone by the power of the Holy Spirit. Anyway, here is what I said in terms broad and inclusive; for truly if there is truth in our doctrinal beliefs, they can be rendered in a way heard by more than just one person who agrees with us; they will be not only spiritual truths but temporal ones, too.
This year’s ThanksGVIN theme is, “From Gratitude to Giving.” This theme implies a very important order of operation when it comes to true, no strings attached, from the heart with gratitude type of giving: we must first be a receiver to become true givers. However, there’s a problem, we work from the opposite: we give to receive. We are transactional, seeking something from every investment of our time, energy, and money. Every charitable donation comes with a receipt and every tithe a tax benefit. We expect “Thank You” notes for gifts given, finding ourselves a bit grumpy when one doesn’t arrive. If we’re honest, our socials are packed with the images of our good deeds to get … likes. We even rope God into our transactions, we believe in God to get heaven; God, in this equation, is not an end but the means to something else. Giving to receive is the symptom of a deeper ontological illness: I am curved in on myself. I am eager to benefit myself, to make myself better, to gain something to elevate myself above my peers. My gift to you is really a gift to me and brings me something; you become another victim in my pursuit of self-justification and self-righteousness. We give to receive.
So, how do we become those who give from gratitude and not for it? Is there any hope for us? Remembrance.
We must remember that we are creatures, created, lacking the ability to summon our own existence. From our first breath, we are dependent on another for our existence. Humans are quite quirky that way; we’re born ¾ done. We are born to receive help, comfort, food and drink, even protection. We are receivers first.
What and who we are today is because of what another did yesterday. We must remember that we are not our own authorities and our own laws (autonomy). We are dependent on others for work and for sustenance. The earth and the cosmos provide us with air, water to quench thirst, soil to bring forth food to satisfy hunger; we are nourished by the sun, the wind, the clouds, and rain. Mountains and shorelines elevate us and bring us low. The moon with her stars and all the planets participate in creations grand provision. We are receivers first.
We are first loved by celestial divine Love before we ever love her in return. Love interrupts us and brings us into her throne room, swaddling us in love so complete that we are liberated from ourselves for others and set on a journey to live a life born of love to give love, to bring life, to liberate those still held captive to themselves and by others. We are receivers first.
When we remember that we have first received then we can give just to give because we give not from our own power, but from the power that was given to us from the beginning, every day, and from heaven. Here, no one is used to satisfy a self-centered end; rather, everyone we give to is seen and valued as they are and for who they are. The gift is just given; love, life and liberation are transferred, given without expectation of return (full stop). Here, in remembering who we are—creatures, created by Love and sustained and nurtured by the love of others—we become a people who give from gratitude and not for it.