The following is the opening portion of a Christmas letter I wrote at the end of 2024. I’ve been meaning to post it, but haven’t gotten around to it…until now. So, here are some random musings from yours truly. If they hit and serve you; I’m glad. If not, leave them behind; I would never want you to be burdened by my own “stuff”.
Christmas 2024
βTherefore, Pilate said to him, βSo then, you are a king?β Jesus answered, βYou, you say that I am a king. For this I, I have been born and for this I have come into the cosmos, so that I may witness to the truth; everyone who is of the truth hears my voice.β Pilot said to him, βWhat is truth?ββ (Jn. 18:37-38)
Truth seems a tricky beast to get a hold of, like grasping at oil or sand. Thereβs a brief moment when I feel like Iβve got it in hand and thenβ¦what I thought was mine is now no longer mine as it spills out from a fist clenched with desperation. Iβve always considered our human travels through time on this rock as the way we accumulate more truth (like coins in a jar). But, looking around here at the end of 2024, Iβm not so sure thatβs the case. I feel no closer to the truth today than I did in January. Sadly, I feel further from it this year than years before. It seems our information landscape is a veritable wasteland of dis- and misinformation; a minefield to navigate with alertness and wakefulness that only ends up producing existential fatigue. I have no choice but to echo Pilate with weak lips, What is truth?
I have a hard time asking this question aloud because itβs often met with scientific, intellectual, philosophical, theological, and party-political pat responses. But truth isnβt fact strictly, and it certainly isnβt dogma or human-made ideology. These are all things drawn from the truth because human beings are eager to make sense of their environments and place in history. Facts and ideologies are material manifestations of the truth that (eventually) become captive to space, decay with time, and will (if we allow them to) die. But truth canβt be confused for these things no matter how comforting that may be; truth refuses capture and denies us the ability to mount it on our wall like a trophy.
If Iβve learned anything this year, itβs that truth isnβt a thing; itβs a summons, a disruption, itβs what liberates us from the captivity of what was. Itβs the thing that gets us to turn our heads towards the future while standing in the present and remembering what was rather than clinging to it; truth beckons us to let go of what we have known and receive something new. So, this is why I dragged Easter into Christmas. Advent is our time of waiting for the arrival of God in our moment; our eager expectation to be flat-out and totally ruptured from what was and is (the status quo). God promises to show up and bring Godβs reign; in the nativity of Jesus Christ God does show up. The birth of Christ is a great and heavenly fracture of geological time and space. But itβs the beginning; the story doesnβt stop there. Behind the manger looms the cross, and itβs in the cross and resurrection event (whether you believe them to be fact and real or not) where the world will never truly be able to go about its business as if something didnβt just happen, as if the earth didnβt just shake, as if the illuminating light of God didnβt stream forth and expose all those who witness it (literally or spiritually, historically and currently).
The birth of Christ is not a light that only shines backward illuminating the past (woe to me a sinner); rather, itβs a beacon that shines forward, illuminating our path forward (surely this man is God). Herein lies truth. Jesus says that he came into the world to witness to the truth of God; this means nothing less than to witness to Godβs reign and mission of love, life, and liberation in the world. Wherever there is indifference, the truth will beckon us to bring Godβs love; wherever there is death, the truth will beckon us to bring Godβs life; wherever there is captivity, the truth will call us to fight for divine liberation of Godβs beloved. According to Jesus at the penultimate Good Friday moment, truth is a voice calling out, summoning me to drop my nets and follow God not backward toward what is familiar and known, but to be ruptured from what was, to go forward, follow Christ and step into the unknown. Dorothee SΓΆlle (German Lutheran Liberation Theologian)writes,
βChristβs truth is concrete.β¦By concrete we mean changeable according to the situation and according to human needs; able itself to change a situation and liberate from oppression. This kind of truth must be realized and so it can be experienced but it cannot be known in advance. It can be made but not determined.β[1]
The divine summons of Advent is into this truth of the reign of God defined by love, life, and liberation.
[1] Soelle, Truth is Concrete, 7-8.











